|
From The Bottom Up with - Joe Chiccarelli (Tori Amos, Beck, Counting
Crows, Shawn Colvin)
“Recording Snare”
Blue: If kick is the foundation of the house, as you've mentioned in past columns,
what is the snare? Describe how the snare fits into the structure of the groove
and what one needs to be mindful of in the studio to help the snare accomplish
its mission.
Joe: Well, the snare would certainly be the first floor of the house. It’s
the thing that most people seem to spot first when they listen to a recording.
How it fits into a groove truly depends on the style of the song and the genre
of the music. It could be a crucial cornerstone as it is in rock, or a subtle
part of the ensemble as it might be in certain types of jazz. Once I ascertain
my picture of the song, I then go about choosing a snare sound that is appropriate.
My first move would be the actual choice of drum -- wood, metal, deep, piccolo,
etc. I then would choose a mic condenser for jazz where the detail is important,
and a dynamic for rock where the power and impact is most important.
Blue: What’s the most important element in getting the right sound for
the snare?
Joe: The choice of drum is the key, and then the tuning is the next step. I
take great care in finding the right character for the song. It might sound
a bit “Spinal Tap,” but I find if I just bang the drum lightly with
my finger I can get a sense of how it will sound for the song. It’s important
to find a sound and pitch for the drum that sits in the right place against
the lead vocalist. Sometimes the pitch of the drum can be right in the same
spot as the vocal, leaving very little room to [allow both to play] an important
role in the song.
Blue: What kinds of things do you listen for in the microphone you choose for
recording snare?
Joe: For rock music I like to get clarity of midrange and the body of the snare
from my top mic. I like the attack to be fast and audible. I might also use
a second top mic that I may compress to add character to the shell tone of the
drum. In most cases I use a bottom mic to gain some of the buzz of the snares.
Blue: Talk a little bit about placement of the mic when recording snare.
Joe: I like to aim my mics at the center of the drum where the drummer attacks
the skin. For my tastes, this is the most focused and quickest sound. Aiming
towars the rim will get more ring and tone but might lack some punch. For phase
consistency I angle my bottom mic in a similar direction but place it electrically
180 degrees out of phase.
Blue: What's the most unconventional technique you've ever used when recording
snare?
Joe: I’ve recorded snares in echo chambers and school hallways, I’ve
recorded them in 4x4 dead vocal booths for that Seventies funk sound, and I’ve
used compressed and gated shotgun mics six feet high over the snare for a live,
aggressive, explosive room tone.
One of my favorite drum recording [techniques] was adding a cassette machine
under the drum. The built-in compression of the AGC limiter in the recorder
made the drum sound hyper-amplified. Every ghost note the drummer played on
his snare came through in great detail.
Blue: Is there a big difference when cutting snare to analog rather than digital?
Joe: With analog it’s important you don’t hit the tape too hard,
because it folds the natural attack on the drum into the tone. That makes the
snare sound lifeless. With digital, the trick is getting the presence and size
without peaking. Digital distortion on snare transients sounds very nasty.
Blue: How does your approach change when you record snare for different genres...rock,
jazz, world, etc.?
Joe: With jazz I tend to go with fewer mics, and I also won’t use that
much processing. I look for an overall natural, well-balanced kit and a lifelike
tone for the drums. With pop and rock I tend to use many mics and then many
more mics for room ambiance. I mix and match and rebalance, compress and EQ
them to fit the particular song. I aim for size and power in the kit.
Blue: It seems like snare would be where both artist and engineer would want
to be most picky with the sound. What’s the weirdest thing you’ve
done for an artist to get just the right snare sound?
Joe: There have been many times where artists have gone around in circles looking
for that sound, auditioning a dozen different snares for a song. Usually the
key is in the tuning and the damping. Lately my favorite trick is to gaffer-tape
the sheet music from the session to the snare drum head. It instantly sounds
thicker and more focused, like a warm Seventies record. If you’re not
using sheet music, a fat wallet comes in handy.
From prestige artists like Julieta Venegas and Cafe Tacuba to critical and
commercial favorites such as U2 and Beck, producer and engineer Joe Chiccarelli
has helped create a wide array of special music during his 25-plus years in
the business. We’re honored he’s agreed to share his thoughts on
recording low-frequency instruments with us in this
More articles
|